This post is a contribution to the February issue of Animist Blog Carnival :
lifthrasirsuccess.wordpress.com/animist-blog-carnival/
on the theme of Animist Ethics, through a blog called animist jottings:
http://animistjottings.wordpress.com/2014/01/07/animist-ethics-call-for-contributions/
on the theme of Animist Ethics, through a blog called animist jottings:
http://animistjottings.wordpress.com/2014/01/07/animist-ethics-call-for-contributions/
The question I ask as a person who feels a strong connection to both Animism and Catholic Christianity is: Can an Animist be a Christian and vice versa? Are they mutually exclusive or can they be compatible?
The Animist Blog Carnival suggests that animism is open to interpretation. Many examples of other's definitions are listed. Graham Harvey’s Animist Manifesto states that
“All that exists lives All that lives is worthy of respect You don’t
have to like what you respect Not liking someone is no reason for not
respecting them Respecting someone is no reason for not eating them” This and other definitions proposed suggests that Animism doesn't have with the Christianity.
But how does Christianity feel about Animism? Clearly Animism has strong associations with pagan religions and Christianity denounces other gods. Christianity is often in competition with other religions for followers. Frequently this competition has led to violence of which Christians were usually, but not always, the cause. Christianity also has a checkered past in respect to its attitude toward and treatment of the natural world. There is a long list of abuses of nature in Christianized countries and a general attitude of disrespect for the non-human world. Yet I maintain that depending on your definition, Christianity does not reject Animism.
Protestant beliefs and teachings on
this and many other subjects, vary widely. Though the voice stating
firmly and loudly that humans are commanded to subdue the earth can
be heard in most churches, and I'm fairly sure many teachers
and preachers turn a blind eye to abuse, condoning and practicing
it, and even claiming scriptural support for these practices, no church doctrine actually teaches
Christians to abuse God's creation. Scripture does not support this destructive behavior, despite such
claims. The Bible, on which all
church doctrine should be based, teaches that the Creator considers
His creation good (Genesis 1) and that He loves everything that
exists. (Wisdom 11:24) And fortunately there are also many voices that speak out in
defense of the Earth.
The Catholic Church teaches that the
word “subdue” used in the Bible (Genesis 1:28) means stewardship,
“not arbitrary and destructive domination.” And that we are
responsible “for the world God has entrusted” to us. (Catechism
of the Catholic Church 373) It further teaches that the use of
“animals, plants and inanimate beings”... “cannot be divorced
from respect for moral imperatives.” Man's dominion is not
absolute. It “requires a religious respect for the integrity of
creation.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2415)
Though Church doctrines teach animals,
plants and minerals are for the legitimate use of humans, for food,
clothing, and experimentation, within reasonable limits, to care for
and save human lives (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2418), an
animist can respect creation while using it.
I maintain that Christianity is a good
home for an animist, because the Catholic Church teaches that “each
creature possesses its own particular goodness and perfection” and
“reflects in it's own way a ray of God's infinite wisdom and
goodness.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church 339) Therefore, “men
owe [animals] kindness.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2416)
And “it is contrary to human dignity to cause animals to suffer or
die needlessly.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2418). Further, “Man
must therefore...avoid any disordered use of things which would be in
contempt of the Creator and would bring disastrous consequences for
human beings and their environment....God wills the interdependence
of creatures. Creatures exist only...in the service of each other.”
(Catechism of the Catholic Church 339-40) In fact, “the truth that
God is at work in all the actions of his creatures is inseparable
from faith in God the Creator.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church
308)
Unfortunately financial gain tempts
many Christians away from these biblical and ecclesiastical
teachings. The lack of focus on the sacredness of God's creation from
the pulpit and in the classroom condones disrespect for nature among
the careless and those looking to victimize.
On the whole, in theory, I would dub
Christianity friendly to the natural world and compatible with Animism, if
a bit anthropocentric. In practice Christians have a long way to go.
Thankfully, there are Christian heroes like St Francis of Assisi ,
who was firmly grounded in respect and communion with the natural
world around him. He has been given the title of Patron Saint of
Animals and is a refuge for animal and nature lovers, in Catholic and
Protestant circles alike, from the more zealous anthropocentric
teachers and participants .
I would love to see Christians more
actively embrace protection of the environment and creation. There
are some organizations within Christianity that are moving in this
direction. Knowing that humans so easily succumb to greed and
destructiveness, we need to shore up the teachings of respect and
care for what our Lord has made. Even if one does not see humans and
creation as equal, one should do what one can to protect what is
voiceless, sometimes powerless, yet wholesome and beneficial.
Ideally the differences of believe of
equality or inequality should not result in different behaviors if
respect and reverence guide the Christian choices. There is doctrinal
room for Christian Animists and all Christians should be
practicing an Eco-friendly religion.
Pope Francis's choices bring me great hope that
simple lifestyles instead of opulence will pervade the decisions of
the Catholic Church, for the good of all people and creation. I would
love to see churches fully embrace environmentally friendly uses of
paper and resources. We must remember we are first a Church of God,
not a business trying to keep ourselves competitive. And further, I
would love to see more Animist Christians filling the pews to call
the careless and the victimizers to a healthier respect for our
natural world.
What do you think the relationship
between Animism and Christianity is and/or should be?
No comments:
Post a Comment